Untrustworthy means not safe to rely on or to confide in. Whatever they promised, do not count on it.
It is one of the most serious things you can say about somebody in a working context, and references avoid it for exactly that reason, since the accusation is hard to answer. It applies to sources and data as well as people, so an untrustworthy witness and untrustworthy figures both mean the same doubt. Unreliable is milder and describes failure to deliver rather than dishonesty.
1adjectiveuntrustworthyNot able to be relied on or confided in.
“The whole account came from an untrustworthy source.”
Also accepted in games: unreliable
From un- + trustworthy.
Etymology from Wiktionary, CC BY-SA